|
On 07/11/2017 11:09 PM, Robert Stryker
wrote:
Hello Rob!
QUESTION 1)
IS SUCH A CHANGE APPROPRIATE
AT THIS TIME? If it's not
appropriate, or cannot be
approved, then we might have
real issues in breaking
these circular dependencies
between repos until the next
major release.
Once that's broken (there are gerrit pushes for
that change), there's still one more issue:
org.eclipse.jst.common.ui (in common) depends on
org.eclipse.jst.common.frameworks (in javaee).
One of these plugins needs to move, either up or
down. Luckily the only things between javaee and
common are jsdt/sourceediting and server. The data
doesn't show either would be affected by either a
move up or a move down.
I believe we can make these changes to be released in Photon. (I'm
curious: why it's not named after Pluto?) And I don't think we need
to rush with those in Oxygen+X releases.
QUESTION 3: Will the servertools lead consent to
a merge of their repos?
Tier 2: jsdt / source-editing. These two have
circular dependencies among themselves. It'd be great
if these 2 projects could figure out a proper
heirarchy, or, alternately, if they'd agree to be
merged into one repo ;)
Right now, I'm like "-1" for such a merge. These are two
"too-different" projects. We just had in HTML Editor the content
assist/validation from JSDT for embeded _javascript_ tags as well as
we made SSE validation to work on JSDT projects (and provided the
according validator) - that's why these two projects became to
depend on each other...
I'd just prefer to make it one-way dependency... Like to make SSE
NOT to depend on JSDT.
QUESTION 4: Are the jsdt / source-editing repos
able to break their circular dependencies? If no, are
they willing to be merged into one repo?
I hope yes, we can make that dependency to be at least 'one way'
Thanks in advance,
Victor
_______________________________________________
wtp-dev mailing list
wtp-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
To change your delivery options, retrieve your password, or unsubscribe from this list, visit
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/wtp-dev
|
