| RE: [cdt-dev] Call for status I200605290500 as RC2 |
|
No worries. I have a good collection of
bugs that I’d like to fix for RC3 that will make things better, and then
there is 3.1.1 and beyond. Since the fast indexer is heuristic based, it will get
better with age J. But there is no denying, it’s fast! Doug Schaefer, QNX Software Systems Eclipse CDT Project Lead, Tools PMC member From:
cdt-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:cdt-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Ploett, Norbert Hi Doug, >
Remember, the criteria for a no-go is that a feature is not testable. > The
vote does need to be unanimous. ok,
that's true, the feature can be tested, though my test results are negative. I wanted
to give a signal that a feature that was worked on even got worse in my
environment, and I realize now that voting -1 was not the appropriate way to do
this. And oooops, I had not thought that the vote actually needs to be
unanimous so that by my veto I can actually stop the world. So
please excuse me for not reading close enough and causing you sweat. In the
light of this please
count me as +1 and so
you have unanimous approval for the release candidate. >
Actually, as a follow up, I am unable to reproduce the problems Norbert is
seeing. The search features work fine for qhull in a Thanks,
Doug, for looking into this so quickly. I am frustrated, but familiar with the
fact that Search features consistently refuse to work for my usecases while
many others are happy. I'll happily help out with more information, testing
scenarios and stuff on the bugzillas. > In
fact, I’d still recommend releasing even with the defect. >
People can still get their work done even without these features. Remember
emacs I do not
fully agree here. I think that source navigation is a key productivity feature
for an IDE and a failure in this area cannot be taken lightly. Yeah, it may not
be worth cancelling a release entirely, and, ok, if it's only me that is
experiencing the bug then the rest of the world must move on, of course. > I
will be in a better mood when 3.1 is out the door Sorry
again for causing you sweat. Hope to
contribute to your happiness in the future. Norbert
Ploett |