Comment 1 Andy Piper 2013-03-04 16:42:32 EST

Request that this be submitted to a new repo:

org.eclipse.paho.mqtt.objc.git

Comment 2 Andy Piper 2013-03-04 17:13:31 EST

Would be great to have Objective-C client available in Cocoapods http://cocoapods.org/

Comment 3 Andy Piper 2013-03-21 18:53:26 EDT

Hi John - there's no code attached here for a CQ - is there anything you're waiting for from us on the Eclipse side?

Comment 4 John Rotach 2013-04-02 17:54:07 EDT

We are close to completing a version of this client with ARC enabled (Automatic Reference Counting).  We plan to submit this version in the next two weeks.

Comment 5 John Rotach 2013-04-08 13:22:44 EDT

Code is ready for submission.  Objective-C MQTT client has been tested in iOS and Mac OS X applications.

Public Github repo:  https://github.com/m2mIO/mqttIO-objC.git

Comment 6 Benjamin Cabé 2013-04-08 13:40:07 EDT

The github repo doesn't seem to include the source code of the client, or does it?

Comment 7 John Rotach 2013-04-08 13:44:09 EDT

My apologies, this is the compiled client which we've already made public.

The source to this client is currently in a private repo.  Do you have a github id we can allow access to our private repo for this submission process?  Our thought is we'd make the repo public after this process but do not wish to at the current time.

Comment 8 Andy Piper 2013-04-08 17:07:25 EDT

Hi John, we're really excited that 2lemetry would like to contribute an Objective-C client to Paho! obviously that covers a key set of target platforms for us :-)

I'm not sure what you know / have been told about how Eclipse works. The starting point here is a Contribution Questionnaire (aka 'CQ') and an IP review of the code being contributed. You could read about this on the wiki http://wiki.eclipse.org/Development_Resources/Contribution_Questionnaire

The upshot is that we do need to have the SOURCE code available. Previous contributions such as the Lua client attached the code as a zip file on the tracking bug. Obviously doing so makes the source code public, whether or not your original git repo is currently private.

Is there a concern about the source itself? The goal here (I think!) is to review the code for IP cleanliness, and then move it into our Eclipse git repository - you'll see I already proposed a name for an appropriate repo for it - so that it can be maintained as part of the wider project from here on out. We'd then make binary releases available as part of a release process for the project, not directly from Git.

Comment 9 John Rotach 2013-04-08 17:58:35 EDT

Created attachment 229471 [details]
Objective-C MQTT Client

Comment 10 John Rotach 2013-04-08 18:00:30 EDT

I have just attached the source code for the client.  We had no specific reason for keeping it private other than we wished to send it through the review process before opening it up.

Let us know what is required of us moving forward.

Comment 11 Andy Piper 2013-04-12 11:07:45 EDT

CQ #7185 created

Comment 12 Andy Piper 2013-04-15 10:44:48 EDT

Under review

Comment 13 Andy Piper 2013-06-24 06:04:47 EDT

*bump*

Last communication with the IP review team indicated that a new version with the appropriate copyright headers and licensing in place would be coming, but we've not yet seen it - so currently stalled in review.

Comment 14 Kyle Roche 2013-06-26 16:48:29 EDT

Source has been added to public repository: https://github.com/m2mIO/mqttIO-objC

Andy, please let me know if you see anything missing. Examples and compiled dist for iOS and Mac included. 

- Kyle

Comment 15 Andy Piper 2013-06-28 12:47:39 EDT

Attached updated code to CQ.

Comment 16 Kyle Roche 2013-08-06 07:49:29 EDT

Hi Andy, is this still under review? Let us know if you're waiting on us for something else.

Comment 17 Ian Craggs 2015-11-19 10:13:31 EST

I'm going to close this bug, as bug 482381 has an updated submission.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 482381 ***