Description David Newcomb 2008-12-02 06:43:50 EST

Build ID: M20080911-1700

Steps To Reproduce:
Set up:

Java->Editor->Save Actions:
  Format source code
    Format all lines
  Organize imports
  Additional actions
  Convert for loops to enhanced for loops
    Add final modifier to private fields
    Remove unused imports
    Add missing '@Override' annotations
    Add missing '@Deprecated' annotations
    Remove unnecessary casts
    Remove trailing white spaces on all lines
    Correct indentation

Attached is a zip containing:
eclipse_clean_up.xml - my clean up settings (just in case you need it)
eclipse_quantel.xml - my formatting settings

Given the following code:

package uk.co.bigsoft.proj.bus;

import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree;

Saving produces:
package uk.co.bigsoft.proj.bus ;

import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree ;

ok - good. Make an edit and save. Produces:

package uk.co.bigsoft.proj.bus ;

import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree;

Spaces are removed. Make another edit and save it to get
your formatting back:
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree ;

It toggles like this all the time.

The most bizzare thing is that if you start with:

import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree ;

and save it, you get:

import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree;

make an edit and save to get back to the invert:

import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectOne ;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectTwo;
import uk.co.bigsoft.proj.dom.ObjectThree ;

The reset of the code formatting is fine. This only happens on the imports.

More information: