Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[wtp-pmc] RE: Request for approval check for JSF and Dali 0.5 releases

All,

 

Below is the “pass” email from Janet re: the Dali and JSF 0.5 releases, along with the URl to the WTP IP log and a snapshot of its content as reviewed.

 

My understanding is that WTP, JSF, and Dali have completed all necessary paperwork and reviews for their respective “Callisto-era” releases. Please let me know immediately if you believe otherwise.

 

-t

 


From: Janet Campbell [mailto:janet.campbell@xxxxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Wednesday, August 09, 2006 11:25 AM
To: Tim Wagner
Subject: RE: Request for approval check for JSF and Dali 0.5 releases

 

Hi Tim,

 

Your IP Log looks great.  All the bases appear to be covered well.

 

Thanks,
Janet

 

Janet Campbell

Manager, Intellectual Property

Eclipse Foundation Inc.

Phone:  (613) 224-9461, x.229 (GMT -5)

Fax:  (613) 224-5172

email:  janet.campbell@xxxxxxxxxxx

www.eclipse.org


From: Tim Wagner [mailto:twagner@xxxxxxx]
Sent: Wednesday, August 09, 2006 1:40 PM
To: Janet Campbell
Subject: Request for approval check for JSF and Dali 0.5 releases

 

Janet,

 

Per our phone call Wednesday. See the second-to-last section titled, “Contribution Questionnaire Reviews for Source Contributions Distributed under EPL” for rows that have “JSF” or “Dali” in the “Subproject” column (3 for JSF, 2 for Dali).

 

Committer lists are earlier in the document and separated by sub project.

 

The IP log can be found on our website at http://www.eclipse.org/webtools/development/ip_log.html and a copy is provided below for your reference. Thanks!

 

Tim

 

 

Web Tools Platform Project IP Log

Committer List

Committer Name

Organization

Phil Avery

IBM

Craig Becker

IBM

Vijay Bhadriraju

IBM

Chris Brealey

IBM

Chuck Bridgham

IBM

Kathy Chan

IBM

Keith Chong

IBM

Der-Ping Chou

IBM

Marshall Culpepper

JBoss

Nitin Dahyabhai

IBM

Naci Dai

Eteration

Tim deBoer

IBM

Larry Dunnell

IBM

Gorkem Ercan

Turkcell

Rob Frost

BEA

Larry Isaacs

SAS

Rupesh Kartha

IBM

Konstantin Komissarchik

BEA

Sinan Konya

Eteration

Jochen Krause

Innoopract

John Lanuti

IBM

David Lauzon

IBM

Jeffrey Liu

IBM

Jens Lukowski

University of Karlsruhe

Richard Mah

IBM

Lawrence Mandel

IBM

Kate Price

IBM

Arthur Ryman

IBM

Craig Salter

IBM

Sheila Sholars

IBM

Raghu Srinivasan

Oracle

Ozgur Tumer

Eteration

Tim Wagner

BEA

David Williams

IBM

Amy Wu

IBM

Susan Yeshin

IBM

CVS Access Policy

WTP committers have access to all code within WTP and to the WTP website content; committers are on an honor system to only edit code with which they are familiar and competent to update. Committers on incubating sub-projects are restricted to operating on their sub-project code (and the corresponding website content, although the latter is on an honor system); when the project exits incubation, its committers are granted full WTP committership rights. Leads of incubating sub-projects are accorded full WTP committer access rights at all times so that they may serve their project's interests in the larger community.

Committer List for ATF Subproject (Incubating)

Checkin permission limited to subproject and related area of website unless name also appears on the general WTP committer list.

Committer Name

Organization

Craig Becker

IBM

Leugim "Gino" Bustelo

IBM

Javier Pedemonte

IBM

Adam Peller

IBM

Donald Sedota

IBM

Committer List for Dali Subproject (Incubating)

Checkin permission limited to subproject and related area of website unless name also appears on the general WTP committer list.

Committer Name

Organization

Max Andersen

JBoss

Christian Ernst

Versant

Paul Fullbright

Oracle

Neil Hauge

Oracle

Markus Kuppe

Versant

Tran Le

Oracle

Dirk Le Roux

Versant

Karen Moore

Oracle

Marc Prudhommeaux

BEA

Shaun Smith

Oracle

Brian Vosburgh

Oracle

Committer List for JSF Subproject (Incubating)

Checkin permission limited to subproject and related area of website unless name also appears on the general WTP committer list.

Committer Name

Organization

Justin Chen

Oracle

Jean Choi

Sybase

Gerry Kessler

Oracle

Raghunathan Srinivasan

Oracle

Ian Trimble

Oracle

WTP PMC

Name

 

Naci Dai

 

Jochen Krause

 

Arthur Ryman

 

Raghu Srinivasan

 

Tim Wagner

Lead

David Williams

 

3rd Party IP Licensed for Binary Redistribution

Note: The Apache Software Foundation license version 2.0 (referred to simply as "ASF 2.0" in the table below) can be found at Apache 2.0 License.

Software

Version

License

Introduced in

Removed since

Notes

Axis

1.1

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

0.7

includes SAAJ

1.2.1

ASF 2.0

0.7

1.0.3

1.3

ASF 2.0

1.5

still in use

Commons discovery

?

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

0.7

 

0.2

ASF 2.0

0.7

still in use

 

Commons logging

1.0.2

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

0.7

 

1.0.3

ASF 2.0

0.7

1.0

 

1.0.4

ASF 2.0

1.0

still in use

 

JAX-RPC

1.1 (part of Axis 1.1)

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

0.7

Source code for this jar is developed/owned by Apache Axis

1.1 (part of Axis 1.2.1)

ASF 2.0

0.7

still in use

log4j

1.2.4

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

0.7

 

1.2.8

ASF 2.0

0.7

still in use

 

Axis-Ant

1.1

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

0.7

 

1.2.1

ASF 2.0

0.7

still in use

 

SOAP

2.3.1

w3c

Initial contribution

0.7

 

Cactus

1.7.2

ASF 2.0

1.5

still in use

Includes cactus-1.7.2 (the one for J2EE 1.3), aspectjrt-1.2.1, commons-logging-1.0.4, and commons-httpclient-2.0.2 jars, and junit 3.8.1

wsdl4j

1.4

Common Public License 1.0

Initial contribution

still in use

includes "qname.jar"

wsil4j

1.0

ASF 1.1

Initial contribution

still in use

 

xerces-j

2.7.0

ASF 2.0

0.7

1.0.3

redistribute binaries in org.apache.xerces plugin

2.8.0

ASF 2.0

1.5

still in use

DOM 3 Interfaces

Level 3

w3c

Initial contribution

still in use

we "redistribute" a few Java Interface classes from w3c, to ensure compatibility if not available in VM, or if Xerces not available

uddi4j

2.0.2

IBM Public License

Initial contribution

0.7

 

2.0.3

IBM Public License

0.7

1.0.1

 

2.0.4

IBM Public License

1.0.1

1.5

 

2.0.5

IBM Public License

1.5.1

still in use

 

http.xsd

WSDL 1.1

IBM, Microsoft

1.0

still in use

License updated from http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/http/wsdl-http.xsd on 6/18/06 for WTP 1.5 release (clarified redistribution language).

soap.xsd

WSDL 1.1

IBM, Microsoft

1.0

still in use

License updated from http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/soap/ on 6/18/2006 for WTP 1.5 release (clarified redistribution language).

soapenc.xsd

WSDL 1.1

W3C

0.7

still in use

License updated from http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/ on 6/18/2006 for WTP 1.5 release.

wsdl.xsd

WSDL 1.1

IBM, Microsoft

1.0

still in use

License updated from http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/ on 6/18/2006 for WTP 1.5 release (clarified redistribution language).

wsdl20.xsd

1.2

w3c

1.0

still in use

 

wsdl-mime.xsd

WSDL 1.1

IBM, Microsoft

1.0

still in use

License updated from http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/mime/ on 6/18/2006 for WTP 1.5 release (clarified redistribution language).

XHTML

1.0, 1.1

w3c

1.0

still in use

we re-distribute this as part of the org.eclipse.wst.html.standard.dtds plugin

WAP DTDs

1.1, 1.3

OMA

1.0

still in use

EPL 1.0 (See notes below, since was permitted upon request).
we re-distribute in org.eclipse.wst.html.standard.dtds plugin

Additional Notes / Email Traces:

  • WAP DTDs: The three files in question are detailed in https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=105535 Namely, our xml catalog entries in
    • publicId="-//WAPFORUM//DTD WML 1.1//EN" uri="dtds/wml11.dtd"
    • publicId="-//WAPFORUM//DTD XHTML Mobile 1.0//EN" uri="dtds/xhtml-mobile10-flat.dtd" webURL="http://www.wapforum.org/DTD/xhtml-mobile10.dtd"
    • publicId="-//WAPFORUM//DTD WML 1.3//EN" uri="dtds/wml13.dtd" webURL="http://www.wapforum.org/DTD/wml13.dtd"

These will be in our org.eclipse.wst.html.standard.dtds plugin.

From: Bengoshi@xxxxxxx [mailto:Bengoshi@xxxxxxx] 
Sent: Tuesday, October 18, 2005 2:12 AM
To: janet.campbell@xxxxxxxxxxx
Cc: alastair_angwin@xxxxxxxxxx; Bengoshi@xxxxxxx
Subject: Re: FW: Redistribution of WAP DTDs within Eclipse 
  
Hello, Janet, 
 
OMA's Legal, Trademark and Regulatory Committee has approved the use of the Eclipse Public License version 1.0 for the WAP DTD's.
 
Best regards,
 
Ann
 
Ann S. Woodliff
Attorney at Law
Phone: (425) 454-9343
 
----- Forwarded by David M Williams/Raleigh/IBM on 10/20/2005 09:14 AM ----- 
"Janet Campbell" janet.campbell@xxxxxxxxxxx
10/18/2005 10:47 AM 
To David M Williams/Raleigh/IBM@IBMUS, "'Adrian Cho'" Adrian_Cho@xxxxxxxxxx
Subject FW: FW: Redistribution of WAP DTDs within Eclipse 
We have received approval to distribute the WAP DTD�s using the EPL v. 1.0. 
  
Regards, 
  
Janet Campbell 
Manager, Intellectual Property 
Eclipse Foundation Inc. 

3rd Party IP provided by other Eclipse projects

Software

Version

License

Other Eclipse project or component

Notes

org.eclipse.equinox.servlet.api

1.0.0

Apache 1.1

The Eclipse Project (Equinox component)

This is a "bundle-ized" version of the servlets.jar 4.1.30 from Apache Jakarta.

Proposals for 3rd Party IP Licensed for Binary Redistribution for Future Releases

Listed for informational purposes only; WTP is NOT able to distribute this IP, but lists these items for tracking purposes and so that downstream projects can determine whether redundant IP requests exist.

Software

Version

License/Use Agreement

Bugzilla

Notes

3rd party (non-EPL licensed) logos

N/A

being determined by EMO

142580 (WTP) and 142579 (EMO)

 

J2EE DTDs/Schemas

1.3 - 1.5 (aka 5)

varies/unclear

104086 tracks the "IBM sourced" approach; no defect for the outstanding Sun query

Some of these state that reproduction is permissible as long as no changes are made; others stipulate that written permission from Sun is required to reproduce/redistribute. Research/investigation with Sun is ongoing.

WSIL DTDs

???

not yet clarified

127679

License/distribution terms have not yet been definitively proven.

Contribution Questionnaires Reviews for Source Contributions Distributed under EPL

Contributor

Committer

Subproject

Bugzilla number

Description

Status

Craig Becker

Craig Becker

ATF

???

Initial contribution

?? has review completed ??

Jean Choi

Jean Choi

JSF

123525

Faces config editor

EMO approved

Xiaonan Jiang

Ian Trimble

JSF

124226 / 126181

EMF model

EMO approved

Lumir Vanek

Gerry Kessler

JSF

133299

Snippets view for JSF RI JSP tags

pending approval

Christian Ernst

Neil Hauge

Dali

135074

UI binding port from ORM project

EMO approved

Karen Moore

Neil Hauge

Dali

N/A (preceded Bugzilla component)

Initial contribution from Oracle

EMO approved

Artur Filipiak

Lawrence Mandel

WTP

122593

WTP Logo

EMO approved

3rd Party IP Incorporated in Source Form and Distributed Under EPL

An automated Bugzilla query to list attachments.


Back to the top