Re: [stp-dev] Last chance for Feedback: SOA Tree Proposal

[Andrea Zoppello <andrea.zoppello@xxxxxx>]

Adrian Mos ha scritto:
> Hi Andrea,
>
> thanks for the comments, see my replies inline:
>
> > I've one doubt. In the proposal you call two components as "Trunk" and
> > "Branches" "Root".... i know this is because this  terms are related to
> > "Tree" but the word "Trunk" and "Branch" "Root" are also
> > common word used by SVN version management system and in my personal
> > opinion it could be confusing to call components name in that way.
>
> yup, I agree that in particular using the combination trunk/branches 
> could be confusing. So I suggest renaming "trunk" to "core" and 
> leaving the others as they are: I think that now, having a "core" and 
> "branches" shouldn't cause too much confusion, since there is no 
> longer the automatic association trunk/branch that reminds of SVN. 
> What do you think?

OK.
> > The other think i want to avoid  is a svn reorganization, if it's
> > possible i want the svn repositories and the "eclipse project names" for
> > the current stuff remain the same.
>
> I think that at least for a while we can certainly leave everything as 
> is. Then in the future we might need to change to match the new 
> branding also because eventually when the new SOA TLP will be created, 
> some changes will inevitable happen. I know it's a pain to do such 
> refactoring, so for the moment let's keep things as they are and 
> analyze the impact of potential changes in a separate thread of 
> discussion later on, maybe in bugzilla, once the project gets created.

Yes it's obvious.. no problem.

Andrea
> cheers,
> Adrian.
> _______________________________________________
> stp-dev mailing list
> stp-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
> https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/stp-dev