Re: [rt-pmc] Fwd: Future of ScalaModules

[Jeff McAffer <jeff@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I too am bummed by this.  Scala and OSGi are both, independently, interesting technologies.  Together they seem to make quite a bit of sense. Some of our commercial partners have been pleased to hear that ScalaModules exists.  My impression from the start of this project was that it was a "no brainer" with good code, existing adopters, and an aggressive schedule. So, like Wayne, I wonder if it is too soon to be terminating.  What will happen to the code and existing users? Will the project continue to be worked on outside Eclipse? 

In a retrospective kind of way, it would be interesting to get your review of the issues and topics that came up for you at Eclipse so we can improve where appropriate.

Jeff

On 2010-07-19, at 4:22 AM, Heiko Seeberger wrote:

Hi,

I decided to terminate the ScalaModules project. Please find the termination review slides attached.

Thank you,

Heiko

On Fri, Jul 16, 2010 at 9:38 PM, Wayne Beaton <wayne@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Well... if we're going to do this right, we're supposed to do a Termination Review [1]. Let me know if you want some help putting the slides together.

Also, can you please inform your PMC of your decision?

Thanks,

Wayne

[1] http://wiki.eclipse.org/Development_Resources/HOWTO/Review_Information_for_Project_Leads#Termination_.28Archive.29_Reviews

Heiko Seeberger wrote:

Hi Wayne,

Thanks for trying, but we started this process in December 2009. That's more than half a year now, which I consider too long. My point of view is: If ScalaModules was a brilliant idea, folks would have jumped upon the train. There is no (business) use case for me to invest even more time into promoting a "rather good" idea.

Heiko

On Wed, Jul 14, 2010 at 5:42 PM, Wayne Beaton <wayne@xxxxxxxxxxx <mailto:wayne@xxxxxxxxxxx>> wrote:

   It seems pretty early in the process to give up. Can I talk you
   into sticking with it a little longer? Perhaps we can drum up some
   interest at Eclipse Summit...

   Wayne

   Heiko Seeberger wrote:

       Wayne, Chris,

       Although ScalaModules has been in incubation for quite a while
       now, we did not manage to attract significant interest from
       possible contributors or users. While lots of folks seem to
       like the fancy idea of combining two "cool" technologies it
       looks like there is no common use case for ScalaModules.

       After talking to the other committers (Roman and Kjetil) I
       decided to stop/withdraw ScalaModules from Eclipse. If I
       understand the Eclipse rules correctly, this would happen
       sooner or later anyway for projects with
       low-level-interest/participation. Anyway, I think that now is
       the time to make that decision.

       Thanks a lot for your help and guidance on the way so long!
       Could you please assist me one last time with this project?
       What are the required steps to take?

       Best Regards,

       Heiko
       Managing Director Technology

       Weigle Wilczek GmbH
       Martinstraße 42-44
       73728 Esslingen
       Deutschland

       T (+49) 711 4599980
       F (+49) 711 45999829
       www.weiglewilczek.com <http://www.weiglewilczek.com>
       <http://www.weiglewilczek.com>


       Geschäftsführer / Managing Directors: Dr. Stephan Wilczek,
       Heiko Seeberger
       Sitz der Gesellschaft / Domicile: Esslingen a. N.
       Amtsgericht / Register Court: Stuttgart, HRB 214442
       USt-Ident.-Nr. / VAT ID: DE 213 472 880


   --     Wayne Beaton, The Eclipse Foundation
   http://www.eclipse.org
   --
   Join me at Eclipse Summit Europe 2010!
   http://eclipsesummit.org/




--
Heiko Seeberger
Managing Director Technology

Weigle Wilczek GmbH
Martinstraße 42-44
73728 Esslingen
Deutschland

T (+49) 711 4599980
F (+49) 711 45999829
www.weiglewilczek.com <http://www.weiglewilczek.com>

Geschäftsführer / Managing Directors: Dr. Stephan Wilczek, Heiko Seeberger
Sitz der Gesellschaft / Domicile: Esslingen a. N.
Amtsgericht / Register Court: Stuttgart, HRB 214442
USt-Ident.-Nr. / VAT ID: DE 213 472 880

--
Wayne Beaton, The Eclipse Foundation
http://www.eclipse.org
--
Join me at Eclipse Summit Europe 2010!
http://eclipsesummit.org/

--
Heiko Seeberger
Managing Director Technology

Weigle Wilczek GmbH
Martinstraße 42-44
73728 Esslingen
Deutschland

T (+49) 711 4599980
F (+49) 711 45999829
www.weiglewilczek.com

Geschäftsführer / Managing Directors: Dr. Stephan Wilczek, Heiko Seeberger
Sitz der Gesellschaft / Domicile: Esslingen a. N.
Amtsgericht / Register Court: Stuttgart, HRB 214442
USt-Ident.-Nr. / VAT ID: DE 213 472 880

--
Heiko Seeberger
Managing Director Technology

Weigle Wilczek GmbH
Martinstraße 42-44
73728 Esslingen
Deutschland

T (+49) 711 4599980
F (+49) 711 45999829
www.weiglewilczek.com

Geschäftsführer / Managing Directors: Dr. Stephan Wilczek, Heiko Seeberger
Sitz der Gesellschaft / Domicile: Esslingen a. N.
Amtsgericht / Register Court: Stuttgart, HRB 214442
USt-Ident.-Nr. / VAT ID: DE 213 472 880

--
Heiko Seeberger

Company: weiglewilczek.com
Blog: heikoseeberger.name
Follow me: twitter.com/hseeberger
OSGi on Scala: scalamodules.org
Lift, the simply functional web framework: liftweb.net
Stambecco, highly scalable computing: stambecco.org
Akka - Simpler Scalability, Fault-Tolerance, Concurrency & Remoting through Actors: akkasource.org
<scalamodules-termination-review.pdf>_______________________________________________
rt-pmc mailing list
rt-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/rt-pmc