RE: [phoenix-dev] Vote for Committer status for Karl Matthias hasstarted

["Nathan Gervais" <nathan.gervais@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Bjorn,

With no disrespect to Karl I'll be voting -1 for a variety of reasons.

Bug 177087 is a Community / Portal issue.  Since the portal is not part of
the phoenix project I don't see how this relates to him being a phoenix
committer.

While I'm sure that Karl has done numerous things as webmaster that affect
the phoenix project on the servers, until there are patches that have been
reviewed, tested, and applied successfully I do not see enough here to
confirm this nomination. 

Bjorn I would like to bring your attention to this url
http://dev.eclipse.org/mhonarc/lists/phoenix-dev/msg00345.html

Replace my name with Karl's name to see what I'm alluding to.

Nathan Gervais
Web Developer
Eclipse Foundation
[http://www.eclipse.org]
 
-----Original Message-----
From: phoenix-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx
[mailto:phoenix-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of
bjorn.freeman-benson@xxxxxxxxxxx
Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2007 11:52 AM
To: phoenix-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: [phoenix-dev] Vote for Committer status for Karl Matthias
hasstarted

technology.phoenix Committers,
Bjorn Freeman-Benson has nominated Karl Matthias as a Committer on the
technology.phoenix project. The reason given is as follows:

Karl has demonstrated both a technical understanding of the website
(servers, PHP, MySQL, CVSes) and the processes we follow to release fixes
(careful and avoid taking the site down). He has built the production side
of the portal as well as Phoenix bugs like [177087]. 

The vote is being held via the MyFoundation portal: voters *must* use the
portal for the votes to be properly recorded.  The voting will continue
until either all 18 existing Committers have voted or until they have been
given enough time to vote, even if they do not do so (defined as at least
one week). Karl Matthias must receive at least three +1s and no -1s for a
successful election.

Eligible Committers must cast their votes through their My Foundation portal
page (do NOT just reply to this email; your vote will not be correctly
recorded unless you use the portal):

    http://portal.eclipse.org/

If you have any questions, please do not hestitate to contact your project
lead, PMC member, or the EMO <emo@xxxxxxxxxxx>

The project Committers eligible to vote are:

    Chris Aniszczyk
    Wayne Beaton
    Bjorn Freeman-Benson
    Lynn Gayowski
    Nathan Gervais
    Susan Iwai
    Anne Jacko
    Mark Johnson
    Jochen Krause
    Howard 2 Lewis
    Maher Masri
    Mike Milinkovich
    Torsten Preissler
    Denis Roy
    Ian Skerrett
    Donald Smith
    Gunnar Wagenknecht
    Todd E. Williams

_______________________________________________
phoenix-dev mailing list
phoenix-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/phoenix-dev