Re: [mylyn-docs-dev] Backlog clean-up

[David Green <david.green@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Jeremie,

Looking through the open reviews on Mylyn Docs it's easy to see that the backlog of reviews is a little out of hand.  Definitely reopen any reviews bugs that you're interested in, especially if there's a corresponding review.  Understanding that we've been unable to get to them in a timely fashion it would be really helpful if you could give me a sense as to which ones are a priority for you, since I'll have a look at those ones first.

There are a few changes (e.g. https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/13578/  https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/14275/ https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/c/10817/ ) where I've responded but haven't heard back from you or you haven't addressed the review feedback.  It's probably best if we start with those.

David

On Mon, Aug 19, 2013 at 3:16 AM, Jeremie Bresson <dev@xxxxxxxx> wrote:

Hi David,

I will reopen the bugs where I have opened a gerrit change (I just need
to find time to do so). 

As I said before, some of my gerrit changes were posted with the idea
to start a discussion (I agree that they are not meant to be merged in
this form). But some patches I proposed are valid contributions that
solve the described issue. I do not understand why they cannot be
merged. They are documented, have an appropriate unit test… (if not
please review the change in Gerrit).

Have you just run a script to close all the bugs? Or have you review
each bug separately? 

I understand that WikiText is not a priority for you and that the time
you can put in the project is limited. I remember having this
conversation per email when I was disappointed in not getting any review
on my patches. But I always thought: this is only a matter of time
before getting a review. I need to understand that the WikiText guys
have the same kind of constraint that I see at work. Open source isn’t a
wonderland even for my first open-source contributions.

Now I see you have closed a lot of bugs, even if a patch is attached to
it. This is a shame for an open-source project!

Take bug 390081 [1] as an example.
Comment 2 <David Green>: … Please re-open if you'd like to see this
revisited, perhaps with a contribution

When my comment 1 is a link to a Gerrit change that never got a review.

If you choose to close everything, to see what the reaction will be.
Here is mine:
-       Disappointed (again)
-       I will reopen every bug, where I was involved and repost the link to
the Gerrit change.

I hope this is what you expected. If not, please let me know.

Jeremie

[1] https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=390081

On Fri, 2 Aug 2013 09:44:00 -0700, David Green
<david.green@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> I've closed all open bugs in Mylyn WikiText as RESOLVED WONTFIX that
> were opened before January 1 2013 as part of backlog clean-up.
>  Please reopen any bug that you'd like to see revisited.  When
> reopening a bug please consider providing a contribution.
>
> Thanks,
>
> David

_______________________________________________
mylyn-docs-dev mailing list
mylyn-docs-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/mylyn-docs-dev

--

David Green

VP of Architecture, Tasktop

Committer, Eclipse Mylyn

http://tasktop.com 

+1-778-588-6896 ext. 115