[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[higgins-dev] Improved i-card.owl checked in
Title: Improved i-card.owl checked in
Sergey,

This is a giant improvement, thank you. I have checked it in here [1].

Questions for you:
  1. I presume that you’ve stayed entirely within the IMI specifications? It seems that you have. That was the intent.
  2. WRT your #16: CDM does (in my mind) support polymorphism although I realize that the IdAS API does not—but we can fix this when we remove the Model APIs from IdAS
  3. WRT your #18: I made these changes, thanks.
  4. WRT your #17: Do you have ideas about how to represent these values?
  5. Would you be willing to create an i-card-instance.owl file that contains an example p-card and an example m-card? If so I’ll turn them into diagrams and I’ll use them to replace the overly simplistic diagrams here [2]. I think that will help folks understand this sub-part of PDM 1.1 (i.e. The i-card.owl part) much better.

--Paul

[1] https://dev.eclipse.org/svnroot/technology/org.eclipse.higgins/trunk/ontology/org.eclipse.higgins.ontology/i-card.owl
[2] http://wiki.eclipse.org/Persona_Data_Model_1.1#I-Cards


On 9/15/09 2:58 PM, "Sergey Lyakhov" <slyakhov@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Paul,
 
I made the following changes to attached i-card.owl:
 
1. I-Card should be able to contain extensions (in xml form).
2. ClaimType should also have the following datatype properties : claimTypeName, claimTypeDescription.
3. supportedClaimType should be object property with ClaimType range.
4. I-Card should have supportedTokenType datatype property.
5. pinDigest should have I-Card as a range (now CardSpace supports it for both m- and p-card, we did not yet implement it for m-card).
6. cardName property missed for I-Card.
7. cardVersion property missed for I-Card.
8. masterKey property missed for I-Card.
9. langId property missed for I-Card.
10. issuer property missed for I-Card.
11. stsPrivacyPolicyVersion missed for M-Card.
12. M-Card should have tokenService object property with TokenService range.
13. TokenService should have endpointReference object property with EndpointReference range.
14. EndpointReference should have address, metadataAddress and certificate properties.
15. TokenService should have userCredential object property with UserCredential range (also, there is CredentialDescriptor class defined in i-card.owl which duplicates UserCredential).
16. UserCredential should be able to contain all forth credential type descriptors. I added them as extended classes of UserCredential, but not sure it is correct. Does CDM support polymorphism?
 
Also the following changes need to be done:
 
17. P-card needs claim values.
18. strongRecipientdentityRequired - the label contains "require aplies to", but this is not quite correct. It meaning is RP should provide a cryptographically protected identity, for example, an X.509v3 certificate. Also "I" is missed in the name of this property, moreover, in CardSpace docs it is named as RequireStrongRecipientIdentity.