Re: [gmf-dev] Bundles and CQs for GMF

[Wayne Beaton <wayne@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

I am concerned that GMF-* may be violating the Eclipse IP Policy. We
need to resolve this.

I cannot find CQs for the handful of libraries/versions that I've cited
below. I need your help to:

* identify an existing CQ that applies for each library/version;
* create CQs for those libraries/versions that do not have CQs; or
* remove the libraries

Please note that CQs for third-party libraries are version-specific.

Wayne

On 03/22/2011 10:13 AM, Anthony Hunter wrote:
> Hi Wayne,
> 
> Here is the full story:
> 
> When we delivered GMF 1.0 in Callisto in June 2006, we delivered Batik
> 1.6 in one bundle in GMF. This is CQ 208. The Batik libraries include
> (repackage) some other apache libraries.
> 
> Then the next year in June 2007 for Europa, we moved the Batik 1.6
> libraries into orbit. We did raise new CQ 2070.
> 
> For the next four releases we continued to stick on Batik 1.6. We never
> raised any new CQ as we still only depended in Batik 1.6.
> 
> We shipped org.apache.xml.resolver 1.1 in Europa, but now we are at
> org.apache.xml.resolver 1.2 in Indigo. I do not know when the switch
> from version 1.1 to 1.2 occurred. This was simply because our build was
> taking the latest version of the library that happened to be in Orbit. I
> think you are telling me this makes a difference. My build just says use
> version 1.x from Orbit and my build gets the latest.
> 
> I can get you the versions of the libraries, but for Europa we shipped
> org.apache.xml.resolver 1.1.0.v200705310020.
> 
> For more information, we also did make an attempt to use Batik 1.7, and
> raised a bunch of CQ for this as well, but this was a big fail and the
> work did not complete, mainly because Batik 1.7 is a breaking release
> with incompatible changes. We never shipped on Batik 1.7.
> 
> p.s. hope you do not mind me copying gmf-dev so everyone is aware of
> this issue.
> 
> Cheers...
> Anthony
> 
> 
> 
> 
> From:         Wayne Beaton <emo@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> To:         Anthony Hunter/Ottawa/IBM@IBMCA
> Date:         03/21/2011 07:30 PM
> Subject:         Re: Bundles and CQs for GMF
> 
> 
> 
> Thanks Anthony.
> 
> However, you do seem to be providing downloads of versions for which I
> cannot find CQs. Per our IP Policy, you are required to have  CQ for
> everything you distribute. Either we need to identify a CQ for each of
> the libraries I listed, or remove them from the download server.
> 
> For example, I am aware that resolver 1.2 is included in Batik 1.6. You
> are distributing this version, but are also distributing version 1.1 in
> the directories I mentioned below. Could this be an artefact from an old
> build gone wrong?
> 
> Thanks,
> 
> Wayne
> 
> On 03/21/2011 03:34 PM, Anthony Hunter wrote:
>> We use in the following versions for GMF-Runtime in Indigo
>>
>> org.apache.xml.resolver 1.2.0
>> org.w3c.dom.smil 0.0.0
>> org.w3c.dom.events 0.0.0
>> org.w3c.dom.svg 0.0.0
>> org.w3c.css.sac 1.3.1
>>
>> All of these come from the Batik 1.6 (CQ 208) .
>>
>> 0.0.0 means we do not have a hard coded version in the feature.xml
>>
>> Cheers...
>> Anthony
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> From:         Wayne Beaton <emo@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>> To:         Anthony Hunter/Ottawa/IBM@IBMCA
>> Date:         03/21/2011 02:15 AM
>> Subject:         Bundles and CQs for GMF
>>
>>
>>
>> Hi Anthony.
>>
>> I am reviewing the IP for the EEP project. EEP consumes EPF which in
>> turn consumes GMF-*.
>>
>> While doing my review, I found a couple of bundles being distributed by
>> GMP/GMF-* on download.eclipse.org that I can't find a CQ for. Can you
>> take a look and let me know where these come from?
>>
>>                                  org.apache.xml.resolver_1.1.0.*.jar
>>                                  org.w3c.dom.smil.source_1.0.0.*.jar
>>                                  org.w3c.dom.smil_1.0.0.*.jar
>>                                  org.w3c.dom_1.3.3.*.jar
>>                                  org.w3c.css.sac.source_1.3.1.*.jar
>>                                  org.w3c.css.sac_1.3.1.*.jar
>>
>> These files are found in:
>>
>> /modeling/gmp/updates/releases/plugins
>> /modeling/gmp/updates/plugins
>> /modeling/gmp/update-site/releases/plugins
>> /modeling/gmp/update-site/europa/plugins
>>
>> Resolver may require that you create a piggyback off CQ87. Or might this
>> come from a version of Batik? AFAIK, Batik 1.6 (CQ 208) includes
>> Resolver *1.2*. Similarly, there are different versions of smil, dom,
>> and css associated with Batik 1.6.
>>
>> Can you help me sort out what's going on here?
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Wayne
>>
>