[gmf-dev] Re: Release Review Materials for GMF Tooling

[Anthony Hunter <anthonyh@xxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi Wayne,

Dash has now been fixed so the committer list is fine.

The contributors list is accurate for Helios. There was only two contribution patches and both are in the log.

I am going to submit the IP Log,

Ed, can you approve the review materials at http://wiki.eclipse.org/GMP/GMF-Tooling/HeliosReview ?

Cheers...
Anthony
--
Anthony Hunter mailto:anthonyh@xxxxxxxxxx
Software Development Manager
IBM Rational Software: Aurora / Modeling Tools
Phone: 613-270-4613


Wayne Beaton ---06/04/2010 04:31:24 PM---Hi Anthony. You really do need to have some confidence in the contents

From:	Wayne Beaton <wayne@xxxxxxxxxxx>
To:	Anthony Hunter/Ottawa/IBM@IBMCA
Cc:	"'Wayne Beaton'" <wayne.beaton@xxxxxxxxxxx>, Ed Merks <ed.merks@xxxxxxxxx>, Cédric Brun <cedric.brun@xxxxxxx>, Anne Jacko <emo@xxxxxxxxxxx>, Gmf-dev <gmf-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx>, Mariot Chauvin <mariot.chauvin@xxxxxxx>, Artem Tikhomirov <tikhomirov.artem@xxxxxxxxx>
Date:	06/04/2010 04:31 PM
Subject:	Re: Release Review Materials for GMF Tooling

---

Hi Anthony. You really do need to have some confidence in the contents 
of the log. The idea of the automated log is to assist you in creating 
the log, not take the place of all reasoning about it. If you are *very* 
confident in the log, then it's probably okay to push the button...

However, a quick look reveals that it shows the project has no 
committers. That can't possibly be right. Dash shows no information 
about the project. I have to assume that the project's SCM repositories 
were only recently specified and Dash hasn't had a chance yet to harvest 
the corresponding information.

We have two choices... Dash should run over the weekend and populate 
itself with data for the project; you can rerun the log and get 
automatic data. Second, you can use the portal to explicitly mark each 
of the committers as active and rerun the log (I believe that will work).

The list of contributions also seems a little short.

HTH,

Wayne

Anthony Hunter wrote:
>
> Hi Wayne,
>
> The greater modeling community wants the GMF Tooling project released. 
> Two modeling projects have released major versions, so we need GMF 
> Tooling released if we want GMF Tooling generation for the Helios 
> modeling platform.
>
> I am concerned that if *I* press submit on the GMF Tooling IP Log, 
> there may be some future ramifications. Realistically, as I am not a 
> GMF Tooling commiter for the GMF Tooling code, I cannot guarantee 100% 
> all of the items in the IP section of the release review materials.
>
> I am mostly confident, but not 100% confident.
>
> What do you suggest here, can I just press submit?
>
> Cheers...
> Anthony
> --
> Anthony Hunter mailto:anthonyh@xxxxxxxxxx
> Software Development Manager
> IBM Rational Software: Aurora / Modeling Tools
> Phone: 613-270-4613
>
>
> Inactive hide details for Ed Merks ---2010/06/04 01:15:08 
> PM---Anthony,Ed Merks ---2010/06/04 01:15:08 PM---Anthony,
>
>
> From: 		 
> Ed Merks <ed.merks@xxxxxxxxx>
>
> To: 		 
> Anthony Hunter/Ottawa/IBM@IBMCA
>
> Cc: 		 
> Cédric Brun <cedric.brun@xxxxxxx>, Mariot Chauvin 
> <mariot.chauvin@xxxxxxx>, Artem Tikhomirov 
> <tikhomirov.artem@xxxxxxxxx>, Gmf-dev <gmf-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx>, Anne 
> Jacko <emo@xxxxxxxxxxx>, "'Wayne Beaton'" <wayne.beaton@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>
> Date: 		 
> 2010/06/04 01:15 PM
>
> Subject: 		 
> Re: Release Review Materials for GMF Tooling
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
>
> Anthony,
>
> I tried, but I believe I have to be a GMF-Tooling committer to do it. :-(
>
> The log's page has an "/(Error: no committers)" /entry, so that 
> doesn't bode well.
>
> Regards,
> Ed
>
>
> Anthony Hunter wrote:
>
>             Hi Ed,
>
>             I am forwarding this onto the gmf-dev mailing list to get
>             more exposure and so everyone knows what is happening.
>
>             We did not hear back from Artem or any of the GMF Tooling
>             committers.
>
>             So Mariot offered and created the GMF Tooling docuware at
>             _http://wiki.eclipse.org/GMP/GMF-Tooling/HeliosReview_
>
>             Someone needs to submit the IP Log
>             _http://www.eclipse.org/projects/ip_log.php?projectid=modeling.gmp.gmf-tooling_
>             *today.*
>
>             Can do this for us Ed?
>
>             Ed, when you get questions back from the EMO about the GMF
>             Tooling, you will have to send on to the gmf-dev list and
>             one of us can attempt to answer.
>
>             Cheers...
>             Anthony
>             --
>             Anthony Hunter _mailto:anthonyh@xxxxxx.com_
>             Software Development Manager
>             IBM Rational Software: Aurora / Modeling Tools
>             Phone: 613-270-4613
>
>
>             Inactive hide details for Ed Merks ---2010/06/01 12:01:52
>             PM---Mariot,Ed Merks ---2010/06/01 12:01:52 PM---Mariot,
>
>             From: 		 
>             Ed Merks _<ed.merks@xxxxxxxxx>_ <mailto:ed.merks@xxxxxxxxx>
>
>             To: 		 
>             Mariot Chauvin _<mariot.chauvin@xxxxxxx>_
>             <mailto:mariot.chauvin@xxxxxxx>
>
>             Cc: 		 
>             Artem Tikhomirov _<tikhomirov.artem@xxxxxxxxx>_
>             <mailto:tikhomirov.artem@xxxxxxxxx>, Anthony
>             Hunter/Ottawa/IBM@IBMCA, Cédric Brun
>             _<cedric.brun@xxxxxxx>_ <mailto:cedric.brun@xxxxxxx>
>
>             Date: 		 
>             2010/06/01 12:01 PM
>
>             Subject: 		 
>             Re: Release Review Materials for GMF Tooling
>
>             ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
>
>             Mariot,
>
>             Thanks!
>
>             Cheers,
>             Ed
>
>
>             Mariot Chauvin wrote:
>             > Hi All,
>             >
>             > Cedric told me that release review materials for GMF
>             Tooling was missing.
>             > I am starting to work on the release review on the
>             eclipse wiki.
>             > Artem feel free to modify, update, correct.
>             >
>             > Cheers,
>             > Mariot
>             >
>             >  
>

-- 
Wayne Beaton, The Eclipse Foundation
http://www.eclipse.org