Re: [equinox-dev] How much of the R4.2 spec is implemented in Equinox

[Thomas Watson <tjwatson@xxxxxxxxxx>]

I'm having issues posting to the forum (where I would prefer to answer this).

The first two lists look correct. Taking a look at the third list:

[*] UPnP Device Service - Not implemented

[*] Remote Services - Not in Equinox. Implemented in ECF at Eclipse RT

[*] Deployment Admin - Not implemented

[*] Auto Configuration - Not implemented

[*] Application Admin - Implemented in the Equinox application container (org.eclipse.equinox.app)

[*] DMT Admin Service - Not implemented

[*] Monitor Admin Service - Not implemented

[*] Foreign Application Access - Not implemented

[*] Blueprint Container - Not in Equinox. Implemented in Gemini at Eclipse RT

[*] Tracker - implemented as part of the org.osgi.util.tracker package. Included in org.eclipse.osgi

[*] XML Parser Service - implemented on VMs that include JAXP (J2SE 1.4 or higher). Included in the org.eclipse.osgi. For embedded VM I know eRCP project at Eclipse RT has implementations available.

[*] Position - implemented as part of the org.osgi.util.position package. Included in the org.eclipse.osgi.util bundle.

[*] Measurement and State - implemented as part of the org.osgi.util.measurement package. Included in the org.eclipse.osgi.util bundle

[*] Execution Environment - No one really implemented really implements this. The VM provides the execution environment and the framework is responsible for the following. Validating Bundle-RequiredExecutionEnvironment. Setting various org.osgi.framework properties to reflect the execution environment. Export the non-java.* packages included in the running execution environment from the system bundle. This is implemented by org.eclipse.osgi.



Tom



Jens Lauterbach ---04/05/2010 04:00:08 PM---Hello,

From:	Jens Lauterbach <jens.lauterbach@xxxxxx>
To:	equinox-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
Date:	04/05/2010 04:00 PM
Subject:	[equinox-dev] How much of the R4.2 spec is implemented in Equinox

---

Hello,

I hope hope I am at the right place. I've asked the following question(s) in the forums  and on irc but never got a answer so I am trying it here.

Right now I am working on a paper in which I am comparing Equinox, Felix and Knopflerfish in terms of OSGi 4.2 compliance.

Therefor I looked around on the Equinox page and found some clues:

If I am correct it seems like all of the core specs are fully implemented. Is that correct?

Core:

		 • Security Layer
		 • Module Layer
		 • Life Cycle Layer
		 • Service Layer
		 • Framework API
		 • Package Admin Service
		 • Start Level Servcie
		 • Conditional Permission Admin Service
		 • URL Handlers Service
		 • Service Hooks

According to the "bundles" page the following Compendium specs are fully implemented:

		 • Log Service
		 • Http Service
		 • Device Access
		 • Configuration Admin Service
		 • Metatype Service
		 • Preferences Service
		 • User Admin Service
		 • Wire Admin Service
		 • IO Connector Service
		 • Initial Provisioning
		 • Declarative Services
		 • Event Admin Service


So I'm curious about the other specs not listed on this page:


		 • UPnP Device Service
		 • Remote Services
		 • Deployment Admin
		 • Auto Configuration
		 • Application Admin
		 • DMT Admin Service
		 • Monitor Admin Service
		 • Foreign Application Access
		 • Blueprint Container
		 • Tracker
		 • XML Parser Service
		 • Position
		 • Measurement and State
		 • Execution Environment


Which of them are implemented right now (4.2 spec)?

You can also find this question in the forums:

http://www.eclipse.org/forums/index.php?t=msg&goto=524932&#msg_524932

Best regards
Jens

_______________________________________________
equinox-dev mailing list
equinox-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/equinox-dev