Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [eclipse.org-architecture-council] On subject of JSR's - JigSaw

On 2017-04-15 8:23 AM, Mikaël Barbero wrote:
Thanks for the link. Very well written. It depicts very well how concerning is the jsr-376. One question: what can we do today about this final draft?

Officially, this spec is not the final draft. The current JSR vote is its Public Review Ballot.

For those who have not memorized the JCP process, here is a snippet from https://jcp.org/en/procedures/jcp2_10

3.4.4 Public Review
Public Review begins when the PMO posts a new draft Specification on the JCP Website and announces its availability for public review and comment.

The Spec Lead is responsible for ensuring that all comments are read and considered. If those comments result in revisions to the draft and those revisions result in major changes (in the opinion of the Expert Group,) then the Spec Lead must send an updated draft (with a summary of the changes) to the PMO at least 10 days before the review period ends. The PMO shall post the new draft and the change summary on the JCP Website at least 7 days before the review period ends and shall notify the public that the new draft is available.

3.4.5 Public Review Ballot
The Public Review Ballot starts when the Public Review closes. At the close of balloting, all comments submitted by EC members with their ballots shall be circulated to the Expert Group by the PMO.

If the Public Draft Specification Ballot fails, the Expert Group will have 30 days to update the draft in response to the concerns raised by the EC and to submit a revised version to the PMO. If a revised draft is not received within 30 days, the original decision by the EC shall stand and the PMO will declare the JSR closed. If a revision is received, the PMO shall forward it to the EC and initiate a Public Draft Specification Reconsideration Ballot. At the close of balloting, all comments submitted by EC members with their ballots shall be circulated to the Expert Group by the PMO. If this ballot fails, the JSR will be closed and the Expert Group will be disbanded. If the JSR was a revision to an existing Specification, the Spec Lead shall resume the role of Maintenance Lead of the current Specification (see section 3.6.)

-- 
Mike Milinkovich
mike.milinkovich@xxxxxxxxxxx
+1.613.220.3223 (mobile)

Back to the top