* Where are we now?
There is [Bug 493753] to track progress. I've created two jobs on
[Jenkins] that could be triggered by the new Gerrit change and expose
their p2 repository:
â [Maven job], [p2 repository]
â [Freestyle job], [p2 repository]
Both jobs are in silent mode, they will not vote back on submitted
[Bug 493753] https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=493753
[Maven job] https://hudson.eclipse.org/ecf/job/ecf-tycho.maven.gerrit/
* Why two jobs?
[Maven job type] tries to provide Maven-specific configurations and
integrations for different jobs:
â [Building a maven2 project - Jenkins - Jenkins Wiki]
â [Maven Project Plugin - Jenkins - Jenkins Wiki]
Unfortunately, Maven job type knows nothing about [POM-less projects]
(which is a plain Maven project that uses [Maven core extensions]) -
Hudson/Jenkins creates internal representation of the project to build
using its own implementation. There is [JENKINS-30058 - Support Maven
Core Extensions] for Jenkins and none I'm aware of for Hudson ([Bug
408661 - Maven 3 build trigger not working for Tycho projects] is the
only relevant one).
Another (more serious) problem is that Maven job type is actually
deprecated ([this post], for instance) and not actively supported by
both Jenkins and Hudson communities. I'm not sure that support for
POM-less projects will be implemented in the foreseeable future.
That's why I've created a freestyle type job that is free from the
limitations of the Maven job type but requires more initial
configuration and (I'm speculating a little here) support in the
[Maven job type]
[Building a maven2 project - Jenkins - Jenkins Wiki]
[Maven Project Plugin - Jenkins - Jenkins Wiki]
[Maven core extensions]
[JENKINS-30058 - Support Maven Core Extensions]
[Bug 408661 - Maven 3 build trigger not working for Tycho projects]
* Where to go?
Either freestyle or maven job type will survive. As I think POM-less
Tycho configuration is the way to go, due to inability to handle
POM-less Maven projects, I'm for freestyle job type. But that's not
(only ;-) ) me who should decide.